
The Sports Advisors is a biweekly roundtable featuring experienced operators —across media, sponsorship, monetization, and technology— analyzing the properties and topics that matter, and the lessons they provide to the broader industry.
In the latest episode, the conversation turns to Major League Baseball's looming labor dispute.
MLB's collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1, and with owners pushing for a salary cap that players have long opposed, a lockout appears increasingly likely. The uncertainty alone creates challenges for teams, brands and media partners. We examine the potential consequences of a work stoppage, revisit lessons from previous labor disputes and, most importantly, identify what organizations can do to protect their businesses while they wait for baseball to return.
The cast for the fourteenth episode in a row includes:
Former Carolina Panthers CEO, former Verizon VP of Sponsorship, and current Encore Sports & Entertainment CEO Nick Kelly.
Former Washington Commanders Chief Strategy Officer, former Shop Your Way Chief Digital Officer, and current Next League Chief AI & Innovation Officer Shripal Shah.
Former Learfield CRO, former WWE Global Head of Sales & Partnerships and Head of International, and current DIRIGO Advisory, LLC Founder John Brody.
Former Fox Sports SVP of Programming, Research and Content Strategy, and current Crakes Media President Patrick Crakes.
As always, you can connect with any one of the JohnWallStreet Advisory Advisors or engage the group as a collective, by sending a note to [email protected]. In fact, we encourage it!
Key insights and takeaways from the 55-minute conversation:
Partner Communication Should Be a Priority Amid Labor Uncertainty
The possibility of a prolonged work stoppage creates uncertainty for teams and their commercial partners. Sponsors will be looking to club executives for guidance, even as those individuals are navigating many of the same unknowns. How organizations manage those discussions and relationships in the months ahead will have lasting implications.
“Communicate. Because you know what Nick [Kelly] needed to do [in his role as Verizon’s VP of Partnerships]? Tell the CEO what he thought was going to happen. And if [an executive gives] him bad information, he loses credibility. And if [the executive doesn’t] give him any information, he loses credibility. You don't have to be a prognosticator, but you have to be a communicator…. Communicate and show [your partners] that this is a trust built over time, [and explain that] you appreciate their hanging [in] with you as something bigger is going on; hopefully for the long-term benefit of the game,” Brody said. “I would [also] say get educated [and] understand the issues [at hand].... Understand and then communicate [them to your partners], and work with your comms people [to make sure everyone understands the talking points, so the messaging is consistent].”
Creators, Alternative Activations Should Be Part of Work Stoppage Engagement Strategy
A work stoppage would limit organizations' ability to feature players in events or use their likenesses in offseason storytelling, removing a primary driver of fan interest and forcing teams to find alternative ways to keep their audiences engaged.
“This is [the] time to tap into creators and influencers… [Remember, teams] can't talk about trades, [they] can't talk about the hot stove issues [like they normally would]. But the people following influencers and content creators aren't following them for those reasons. [So,] if there's a way to tie [them] back to your brand, that's a way to stay relevant and provide a reason for someone to stay [engaged] with you in these sorts of dead periods,” Shah said. “How do you actually leverage [those individuals and the content they create]? Maybe it's an Xbox video game tournament at a fan fest featuring alumni…. [Introducing] new merch using the team's brand [is another way. Different types of] content or activations.”
Lockout Creates Two Sponsor Battles: Protecting Budgets and Justifying Renewals
A lockout would create a different set of challenges for the league’s corporate sponsors, whose marketing calendars and business objectives remain unchanged regardless of whether games are played.
Brand marketers must “fight internally to protect money so when the season does come back, [it’s there to spend]. Let's say [baseball] comes back in June and all of a sudden says, ‘we're going to run a bunch of double headers’, and [they are] only actually losing 5% of the season. You can't have given that money back already. And it's a fight because once [other business unit leads, who] are used to seeing [adverts] in April in the marketplace, don't see [them] anymore, they're going to think they can take your [budget]. It is a really hard internal challenge in the short term,” Kelly said. “In the long term, the biggest challenge is going to be if you're a Coca-Cola or a Pepsi, for example, you've trained yourself over the last 30 or 40 years that losing a property will have a dramatic impact on your business in that market. So, if you're [Coca-Cola] and you've been sponsoring the Cleveland [Guardians] because you [believe it helps] sell a million bottles of Coke and water and you make Cleveland [Guardians] retail programming for all the grocery stores and [convenience] stores, and you're not running that programming in [next] spring and there is no impact to your business, you may not be up for renewal [in 2027], but the conversation a year and a half from now [is not going to be easy]...If [the company doesn’t] lose any market share and just saved $3 million on a team deal because [there was no] baseball going on, that becomes an insurmountable fight internally to win [with the CFO] when you go back up for renewal.
Attendance Should Take Precedence Over Gameday Revenue Post-Work Stoppage
The 1994–95 MLB strike showed that the resumption of play does not necessarily mean an immediate return to normalcy. Attendance at MLB home games in early 1995 was ~20% below the prior year's level. Teams will need to rebuild goodwill to win back disengaged fans and remind those individuals of the role it plays in fostering a shared sense of belonging.
“You [are going to] want the stadiums full. So, maybe [you] take it on the chin economically [next] year at the stadium because you've got to work some levers; [like] you need to have [a post-game] concert and [must] pay for it [or] you've got to provide discounted tickets,” Crakes said. But “it should be a brand goal [for the organization] to have [the] stadium as full as possible, regardless of the performance of the team. [Because you want to be able to] say, We're back. We get it. [The lockout] was hard. [But] we've got a bright future in front of us for the team, for the community, for the players. And [returning to the venue] is the first step. Let's celebrate and come together as a community.”
📺 Watch the full episode on JohnWallStreet’s YouTube page.
🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Catch previous episodes of The Sports Advisors on JohnWallStreet’s YouTube channel, including discussions on the Saudi Public Investment Fund’s decision to stop funding LIV Golf, Vancouver Whitecaps FC potentially relocating to Las Vegas, the 2026 World Cup serving as a stress test for the modern sports business model, a sports betting reality check, challenger leagues as investments, premium sponsorship inventory, local sports media, making MLS Major League, the USTA and U.S. Open, LSU vs SEC what comes next for WNBA, TV bundle economics and the future of national rights, and maximizing the value of a championship.
Don’t forget to like and subscribe!
The next episode will be released on Thursday, December 10.
Editor’s Spotlight: Last Thursday, the sixth annual ESPN Edge Innovation Conference returned to The Walt Disney Company’s New York headquarters.
Sessions covered the next era of content creation, immersive sports experiences, how leagues are using innovation to better serve fans, and ESPN’s plans for its first Super Bowl (LXI).
Speakers came from the ACC, Cosm, ESPN, the NBA and TMRW Sports, along with ESPN Edge Innovation partners Accenture, Meta, Microsoft and WSC Sports.
ICYMI: you can watch the full event here.
On the latest episode of JaneWallStreet Presents: At The Table, a biweekly podcast exploring the intersection of sports, media, and finance through the lens of (mostly) female decision-makers, JaneWallStreet Executive Chair Deirdre Lester sits down with Siegelman Stable Founder and CEO Max Siegelman.
In this hour-long conversation, the two surface and explore a range of actionable insights, including: use local licenses to break into sports, why women’s sports fashion has room to run, and how authentic cultural partnerships enhance the fan experience.
📺 Watch the full episode on JohnWallStreet’s YouTube page.
🎧 Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Don’t forget to like and subscribe!




